Skip to main content

Video of 41 bus question


John O Shea has said there was something wrong with the phrasing of the question. What exactly is wrong with this:

“At the weekend, National Express group cancelled without consultation the number 41 bus in Birmingham, causing major problems for people in Birmingham.”

“This is symptomatic of a national problem. When will the rest of the country be allowed to use the same system for bus management as exists in London?”

The good news is that we are close now to having a proposal for a replacement service. However, this should not have happened in the first instance.

Comments

news editor said…
This comment has been removed by the author.
12:06 pm
John Hemming said…
In the light of the second part of the question this is quite clear. In any event you would not expect consultation just for one bus to be cancelled.

It does, however, demonstrate that this is a national problem.
1:02 pm
Stephen Booth said…
Just looking at the question the two things that leap out at me are that there's a statement of the cancellation of a service being 'symptomatic of a national problem' without a definition of what problem is being referred to or evidence of the problem or why this is a symptom of it, and there is a presumption int he question that at some point in the future the rest of the country will be able to use the same system of bus management as London (whatever that system is).

I don't use the 41 service so cannot comment on it.

I have noticed on a number of services (mostly the 37 but that's the service I use the most so obviously I'm more likely to notice things relating to that service) that there seems to have been a reduction in services run by TWM (i.e. National Express Group), that will accept bus passes, which are replaced by independent companies that either do not accept passes at all or only accept the more expensive 'Network' passes which also cover train and Metro travel. This is, I admit, a purely subjective and non-quantitative observation. Might this be related to this undefined national problem?
7:20 pm
John Hemming said…
The national problem (outside London) is that there is in fact relatively little bus regulation.

That is also behind what happens with the passes.

In questions of the prime minister there is a limit as to how much detailed analysis can be spoken of.
7:29 pm
Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Why are babies born young?

Why are babies born young? This sounds like an odd question. People would say "of course babies are born young". However, this goes to the core of the question of human (or animal) development. Why is it that as time passes people develop initially through puberty and then for women through menopause and more generally getting diseases such as sarcopenia, osteoporosis, diabetes and cancer, but most of the time babies start showing no signs of this. Lots of research into this has happened over the years and now I think it is clear why this is. It raises some interesting questions. Biological youth is about how well a cell functions. Cells that are old in a biological sense don't work that well. One of the ways in which cells stop working is they fail to produce the full range of proteins. Generally the proteins that are produced from longer genes stop being produced. The reason for this relates to how the Genes work (the Genome). Because the genome is not gettin...
1 comment
Read more